FoundersOnly

How to post an idea here so that it gets tested, not applauded

#1

This section is for testing ideas before you build them. Encouragement is easy to find elsewhere. What you will get here is questions.

Include in your post:

  • The customer. A specific person in a specific situation.
  • The problem. What goes wrong for them, and how often.
  • What they do about it today. There is always something.
  • What that costs them in money, time or risk.
  • Your idea, in two sentences.
  • Your evidence. Conversations, searches, a waiting list, pre-orders. Say what you have and what you do not.
  • What you would need to see to carry on, and to stop.

When you reply:

  • Ask how they know. "Who told you this is a problem?"
  • Point to where the idea is most likely to break.
  • Suggest the cheapest test that would settle it.
  • If you are the target customer, say whether you would pay and what you pay for now.

House rules

  • Ideas are cheap. Nobody here is going to steal yours, and the feedback is worth more than the secrecy.
  • "I would use this" is not evidence. "I pay 40 a month for something worse" is.

Your perspective belongs here.

Register to reply